Review and Giveaway: Are We French Yet?

Are We French YetAre We French Yet?
Keith & Val’s Adventures In Provence
(travel memoir)
by Keith Van Sickle

Release date: December 15, 2018
at Dresher Publishing

157 pages

Author’s page | Goodreads

Keith and Val started telling about their unusual experience in One Sip at a Time: after some time spent in Switzerland, they discovered how much they like life in Europe. They decided then to split their time every year between California and Provence. Are We French Yet? features their most recent trips.

This time, the author relates his experience through 34 vignettes. It’s neat to see how, through multiple months spent in Provence, and much effort to learn the language, he and his wife get a better understanding of the culture and develop deep friendship with several of their acquaintances. For me, that’s the ultimate goal of genuine globalization.

What I really like about Keith’s books is that his humor (some passages are totally hilarious) is totally a propos and on target, for instance on the language, on strikes and demonstrations, on paper work, and French scarves!

There are obviously, how could there not be, delicious passages on food and wine. The author also highlights some unique French traditional traits, that are alas slowly disappearing, such as the world and ambiance of small local butcher’s shops and the like.

French have the reputation to always being very critical. I don’t remember actually if Keith features this in his book, but as I’m French, I do feel the need to mention a few things I disagreed with:

  • “They don’t’ have Yellow Pages here”, page 6. Actually yes, the French do have white and yellow pages, they are just of course called Les Pages blanches and Les Pages jaunes. I believed they started in 1998. When I was a child, we had them in big telephone books, but as you see, they even exist on line now, just like in the US.
  • The members of the Académie française “are so revered they’re called Immortels”, page 31. That’s not the reason. They are called Immortels because of the motto present on the seal given to them by their founder in 1634-1635, Cardinal Richelieu. The motto says, To Immortality!
    Another reason is that you are appointed a member of the Académie for life. So the number of members is always the same. They are always 40. A new member is elected when one of them dies, and his/her seat needs to be occupied by a new member.
    Recently, no less than 13 candidates were vying for the place freed by Michel Déon’s death. And no one got enough vote, so the seat is still vacant. It’s the second or third time they hold an election to try to fill in that seat!
  • On page 96, the author wonders, “has anyone ever actually read all seven volumes of Proust’s masterwork? I think non”.
    Eh bien si ! And I personally did. I read the very first volume decades ago. Then in 2013, at the occasion of the one hundred anniversary publication of the first volume, a Goodreads group decided to read all 7 volumes, with chapters assigned per week (great for a read-along). I joined them (a fairly large group), but I couldn’t keep up with the pace. I finished the 7th book in April 2016. It was an amazing experience. Some books were harder than others, I remember especially boring scenes in volume 3, but the last volume is so beautiful, I’m glad I persevered.
    And I have a friend in France who has been reading the whole thing at least 5 times: when she’s done, she starts all over again. I can understand the benefit of doing this, as the work is so rich, you definitely need several readings to see all the connections between the various volumes.
  • On page 115, he talks about his classes on “the subjonctif tense”, and goes on saying, “This is a hard one, because there’s no equivalent in English”.  Sorry, but the subjunctive is not a tense (even good old wikipedia will tell you that), as it has nothing to so about past/present/future. It is rather a grammatical mood, by which you convey an attitude or opinion to what you are saying.
    And there IS an equivalent in English, even though I’ll admit there are just a few remnants of it in modern English. But if you speak proper English, you will say, “If I were you, I would read this book”.  Perfect example showing that were is has nothing to do with the past tense, in which case it would be was. This conveys the idea that actually, it’s impossible for me to be completely you.
    Another example could be, “I suggest that you be careful”. We see the more common indicative mood is not used here, otherwise it would be you are. Here, the use of the subjunctive conveys this is just a suggestion, and I don’t know if you will follow my advice and do what I say. So your being careful may or may not happen. For this reason, when I teach the subjunctive, I call it the mood of virtuality.
  • Finally on page 182, the author highlights a special meaning of brave in Provence. As I knew of that meaning both in Champagne and Burgundy regions, where I lived, I double checked in the Larousse French dictionary. Both meanings are listed, and not as something regional.

These points are anyway very incidental and did not lessen my appreciation of Are We French Yet?

The couple’s experience, enriched through the contact of two cultures, has changed their perspectives and attitudes. I’m curious to see where this life adventure will eventually lead them.

VERDICT: Nice collections of funny and culturally aware vignettes highlighting how life can be enriched by being familiar with two cultures.

  rating systemrating systemrating systemrating system

Have you read any other good
about living within two cultures?


In full compliance with FTC Guidelines, I received this book free of charge from the author. I was in no way compensated for this post as a reviewer, and the thoughts are my own.


One Sip at a Time Keith Van SickleKeith Van Sickle
is the author of the Amazon best-seller
One Sip at a Time: Learning to Live in Provence.
A lifelong traveler who got his first taste of overseas life
as a university student in England,
Keith later backpacked around the world on his own.
But it was the expat assignment to Switzerland
that made him fall in love with Europe.
With his wife Val and their trusty dog Mica,
he now splits his time between California and Provence,
delving ever deeper into what makes France so endlessly fascinating.

Find the author on Facebook and Twitter
Visit his website

Subscribe to his mailing list and get information about new releases.

Buy The Book On Amazon.Com



You can enter the global giveaway here
or on any other book blogs participating in this tour.
Be sure to follow each participant on Twitter/Facebook,
they are listed in the entry form below

Enter here

Visit each blogger on the tour:
tweeting about the giveaway everyday
of the Tour will give you 5 extra entries each time!
[just follow the directions on the entry-form]

Global giveaway open to all
5 winners



Are We French Yet Banner


16 thoughts on “Review and Giveaway: Are We French Yet?

  1. Pingback: Keith Van Sickle on tour: Are We French Yet? | France Book Tours

  2. As Deb has already said, your critiques are gentle and kindly meant, springing from your knowledge (long live the subjunctive mood!), and quite interesting to read. And they don’t reduce the impression that this was a worthwhile, enjoyable book on becoming personally acquainted with a famous region of France!


  3. Pingback: Are We French Yet?: tour quotations | France Book Tours

  4. Pingback: Nonfiction November: My Year 2019 in Nonfiction | Words And Peace

  5. Pingback: Six degrees of separation: from a Japanese American author to a Japanese nuclear power plant | Words And Peace

What do you think? Share your thoughts, and I will answer you. I will also visit your own blog

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.