Book review: Carnegie’s Maid

Carnegie's MaidCarnegie’s Maid

by Marie Benedict
Sourcebooks 1/16/2018
Genre: Historical fiction
Pages: 288

As a lover of books, I assume you are one if you landed on my book blog, you have probably entered a Carnegie library at least once in your life.
The first to offer free access to libraries for all, Andrew Carnegie was an important figure in the life of the author’s ancestors. In Carnegie’s Maid, Marie Benedict uses the skills she demonstrated in The Other Einstein to try to shed light on the transformation of the man, from a “tycoon, long-rumored to be heartless”, into “the world’s first philanthropist”.
She followed some historians’ theory that his metamorphosis may have been inspired by a personal relationship.

The book opens in 1868, with Andrew Carnegie writing a letter and trying to honor the memory of a certain Clara.

We then follow Clara from November 1863 to April 1867.

To help her desperate family losing farm land and fearing starvation in Ireland, a 19 year old crosses the Ocean in 42 days to find a job in Pennsylvania. Having no technical skills to offer, despite the excellent education she received at home, rare at the time for young girls, she uses her cleverness and ends up being hired as a lady’s maid at the service of Mrs Carnegie.

A smart observer, “elegant in her thinking” (chapter 15), she will straddle the difficult gap between servants and masters and do all she can to save her family. How will she manage, at what cost?

This is actually a superb portrait of life in the US in the 1860s, with all that’s going on:

  • the aftermath and impact of the Civil War, with the industrial forces at play

  • industrialization, with its horrors and filth; business dealings, iron, railway, telegraph; investing

  • the evolving situation of slaves

  • the difficult relationships between Catholics and Protestants

  • the situation also in Ireland

  • the circumstances of immigrants

  • the relationships between servants and masters, how downstairs and upstairs can or cannot mingle

Why didn’t anyone tell me that industrialization would look like biblical hell?
Chapter 4

All the immigrants…who came to America seeking a better life but settled instead for a soot-infested home and dangerous work in the mills.
Chapter 11

By playing the part of perfect servant, by definition deaf and blind to the events occurring before me, I was present for the most confidential of conversations.
Chapter 29

Mr Andrew Carnegie is presented as a complex character, difficult to understand. His evolution and his inner struggles made total sense. His relationship with Clara is shown with a lot of balance. This is NOT a historical romance, the author managed skillfully to avoid a possible trap.

I don’t want to give away anything. The book is smartly built, with a constant tension with dangers looming in Clara’s family, with the possibilities of losing her position, and the risks in her relationships with the Carnegie’s family, and how she uses her mind to come up with a solution, whatever the price.

I also enjoyed a lot the character of John Ford, the cook, a former slave.

The book is ultimately a homage to libraries, to books and to the love of learning in order to succeed in life and help others. We see the importance of books in the education and evolution of Clara and of the Carnegies.

I listened. And I learned.
Chapter 18

This library, he maintained, made him into a successful man…
I had never heard of a library open to the public without a hefty subscription fee…
I cannot describe to you the impact that library had on my life and my success. It quite literally made me who I am today.
Chapter 18

Just as Marie Benedict gave voice to the unrecognized Mrs Einstein, here through a woman with a strong character, she superbly gives “voice to the otherwise silent stories of the thousands of immigrants who built our country. Then and now”.

VERDICT:  Superb portrait of the US in the 1860s. A beautiful homage to immigrants, to the love of learning, and to libraries.

Rating systemRating systemRating systemRating systemRating system

What other book highlighting the role of libraries have you read?

Eiffel Tower OrangeEiffel Tower OrangeEiffel Tower Orange

In full compliance with FTC Guidelines,
I received this ebook for free from the publisher through Netgalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.
I was in no way compensated for this post as a reviewer, and the thoughts are my own.


















16 thoughts on “Book review: Carnegie’s Maid

  1. Pingback: Bout of Books 21: Day 2 | Words And Peace

  2. Pingback: Bout of Books 21: Day 3 | Words And Peace

  3. Pingback: Bout of Books 21: Day 4 | Words And Peace

  4. Pingback: Bout of Books 21: Day 5 | Words And Peace

  5. Pingback: Bout of Books 21: Day 6 | Words And Peace

  6. Pingback: Bout of Books 21: final recap | Words And Peace

  7. Pingback: 2018: January wrap-up | Words And Peace

  8. Pingback: Mailbox Monday October 29 | Words And Peace

  9. Pingback: The top 8 books to read in December | Words And Peace

  10. Pingback: Mailbox Monday December 10 | Words And Peace

  11. Pingback: Book review: The Only Woman in the Room | Words And Peace

  12. Pingback: Book review: Lady Clementine | Words And Peace

What do you think? Share your thoughts, and I will answer you. I will also visit your own blog

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.