I LOVE FRANCE!
I plan to publish this meme every Thursday.
You can share here about any book
or anything cultural you just discovered related to France, Paris, etc.
Please spread the news on Twitter, Facebook, etc !
Feel free to grab my button,
and link your own post through Mister Linky,
at the bottom of this post.
Confessions of Marie Antoinette
(Marie Antoinette #3)
Release date: tomorrow, September 24, by Random House/Ballantine
In full compliance with FTC Guidelines,
I received this book as an egalley for free from the publisher
via Edelweiss in exchange for a fair and honest review.
I was in no way compensated for this post as a reviewer,
and the thoughts are my own.
This book counts for the following Reading Challenges:
MY THOUGHTS ABOUT THIS BOOK
As I read the first volume of this trilogy, Becoming Marie Antoinette, then the second, Days Of Splendor, Days of Sorrow, I thought I had to read the last one: Confessions of Marie Antoinette.
My favorite of all three remains the first. Though it sounds like the author read my review of the second: in the third volume, there are far less French words used, and with fewer mistakes as well. There are still some, but not as many as to make me list them as I did in my 2nd review!
In this book, we are just before and during the French Revolution, and eventually the arrest and death of both Louis and then Marie Antoinette.
I’m very divided about this book. I do acknowledge that the author seemed to have done a lot of serious research about her main character. But sometimes I had the feeling she wanted to crammed in all the information she had found, and it didn’t seem she was too successful at integrating these data in the novel format.
I guess there’s also a good sense of urgency and suspense, though having studied over and over again these events in history classes, I could not feel any effect of surprise.
Not sure the character of Louison, a young sculptress witness to the events, was all that necessary, at least the way she was presented. When she appeared in the story, I could not but think of how Michelle Moran used another artist, Madame Tussaud, to draw her majestic painting of the French Revolution. Madame Tussaud was at the heart of the story, stuck between royalists and revolutionaries, therefore telling the story from her point of view was pure genius. Louison here is not enough present to make her a significant voice.
The art of historical fiction is very difficult, and I have run into fantastic writers recently, so I guess I’m getting very choosy, and I expect a perfect merge of data into a novel form, not suddenly a few pages that look like my French history text books.
Also, if I consider the whole trilogy, I’m not sure I’m in the presence of the same character. People evolve, definitely, but I did not feel any smooth transition between the superficial Marie Antoinette of the 2nd volume and the mother so loving towards her children in the third.
Again, I may be comparing Juliet Grey to too high a standard, as I remember the amazing evolution of the character of Cromwell between the first and second volumes by Hilary Mantel. But, hey, if someone is able to do it at perfection, it IS possible to attain and repeat, maybe.
Having visited La Conciergerie, where Marie Antoinette was held a prisoner at the end of her life, made some scenes very real to me. My friend guide at the Basilica of Saint Denis, where she has been reburied, (have you seen my pictures of this gorgeous church?) even told me that every week, some devotees bring red roses to put on her tomb!
So whether this book really tells Marie Antoinette’s confessions or not, she is still dear to the heart of many people!
The secretary office . He kept a record of all the belongings of the prisoners as they entered
Marie Antoinette’s cell has been reconstituted:
As you can see, she was under the constant vigilance of a guard, after she tried to escape – she almost made it!
Juliet has many pages on these guards and Marie Antoinette in her cell.
I wrote a special post on La Conciergerie, with more pictures, and more details on its history.
WHAT IS IT ABOUT
Confessions of Marie Antoinette, the riveting and sweeping final novel in Juliet Grey’s trilogy on the life of the legendary French queen, blends rich historical detail with searing drama, bringing to life the early years of the French Revolution and the doomed royal family’s final days.
Versailles, 1789. As the burgeoning rebellion reaches the palace gates, Marie Antoinette finds her privileged and peaceful life swiftly upended by violence. Once her loyal subjects, the people of France now seek to overthrow the crown, placing the heirs of the Bourbon dynasty in mortal peril.
Displaced to the Tuileries Palace in Paris, the royal family is propelled into the heart of the Revolution. There, despite a few staunch allies, they are surrounded by cunning spies and vicious enemies. Yet despite the political and personal threats against her, Marie Antoinette remains above all a devoted wife and mother, standing steadfastly by her husband, Louis XVI, and protecting their young son and daughter. And though the queen and her family try to flee, and she secretly attempts to arrange their rescue from the clutches of the Revolution, they cannot outrun the dangers encircling them, or escape their shocking fate. [Goodreads]
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
has extensively researched European royal history
and is a particular devotee of Marie Antoinette.
She and her husband divide their time
between New York City and southern Vermont.
WHICH OF THE THREE VOLUMES OF THIS TRILOGY
DO YOU PREFER?
Just a reminder guys:
please if possible
include the title of the book or topic in your link:
name of your blog (name of the book title or topic):
Pingback: 2013 – Books on France challenge – My list | Words And Peace
Pingback: Historical Fiction Reading Challenge 2013 | Words And Peace
Pingback: 2013 Ebook Reading Challenge | Words And Peace
Pingback: 2013: September wrap-up | Words And Peace
Historical fiction is tricky for me, too. I want to know enough to understand the situation but there’s a reason that I picked up a novel instead of a history book.
hmm, not sure I understand why you say it’s tricky
Pingback: Six degrees of separation: from Alexander McCall Smith to Sherlock Holmes | Words And Peace
Pingback: I love France #6: #69 Review: Becoming Marie Antoinette | Words And Peace