I love France #24: (2012) #34 Review: Days of Splendor, Days of Sorrow

I LOVE FRANCE!

I plan to publish this meme every Thursday.
You can share here about any book
or anything cultural you just discovered related to France, Paris, etc.

Please spread the news on Twitter, Facebook, etc !
Feel free to grab my button,
and link your own post through Mister Linky,
at the bottom of this post.

*******

Click on this image if you want to join

***

Days of Splendor, Days of Sorrow:

(Marie-Antoinette #2)

by

Juliet Grey

427 pages

Published by Random House in May 2012

Ebook provided by NetGalley & Random House


THIS BOOK COUNTS FOR THE FOLLOWING READING CHALLENGES

 

MY THOUGHTS ABOUT THIS BOOK

Last year, I reviewed Becoming Marie-Antoinette, by the same author, and enjoyed it a lot. So I eagerly read the sequel, Days of Splendor, Days of Sorrow, but that was not such an enjoyable experience.

In this 2nd book, Marie-Antoinette is presented as a very shallow person, with the excuse basically that she would have been a much more profound person if she had had children earlier in life. A lot of the book has to do with her clothes and hair-do. Were these really her only interests in life, and oh apart from her possible lover Axel von Fersen?

Talking about children, it seems also that Juliet Grey’s position about Louis XVI’s sexual problems is not going along current historians theories. This article, published in 2002, is a good example.

Another dubious point is the famous quotation: “If they don’t have bread, let them eat cake.” [By the way, I know this is the traditional English translation, though the French brioche is really not at all cake: it is bread, enriched with butter, milk, and eggs.] Juliet Grey tried to dissociate herself from the popular attribution of this sentence to Marie-Antoinette, which is probably a good thing, but she has Maria-Theresa of Spain say it, which is probably just as wrong. It would have been better just to ignore the whole thing, instead of mentioning it in passing (this is page 17.)

The book expands a lot on “l’affaire du collier”, and its effect on Marie-Antoinette’s reputation. It ends on the eve of the French Revolution, before the royal couple’s trying to escape.

The one thing I really liked in the book is the connection made with the American revolution, and how one influenced the other.

Now, more on the editing level, I was annoyed by the large number of French words used: it seemed very artificial to me to insert words just like fenêtre (window), or others, and there were a lot of them, especially in the first half of the book. AND the problem is that many of these French words or expressions had mistakes! This was an egalley, so I hoped that the final version would be better. I checked everything thanks to the search option available on amazon, and unfortunately, many mistakes are still in the final version. I am very surprised, as I thought Random House was usually doing a great job. There was a whole sentence in French with three mistakes in it, and thankfully the whole sentence is gone in the final version.

But the following are still there:

  1. p.30 and p. 406 in the glossary: c’est divine [instead of: c’est divin]
  2. p.31: elle a partie [instead of: elle est partie]
  3. p. 57: a petit tempête [instead of: a petite tempête – and really, if you put the adjective and the noun in French, why not the article: une]
  4. p.165: son Majesté [instead of: Sa Majesté – yes, we use the feminine form even for the King, as the noun majesté is feminine. The French always prefer the grammar over the meaning!]
  5. p.213: premier chirugien and p. 410 [instead of: premier chirurgien]
  6. p.218: and and enjoy: editing problem even in English!
  7. p. 236: c’est finis [instead of: c’est fini]
  8. p.237: a heathy babe
  9. p.326: the the prisoners
  10. p.336: absoluement [instead of: absolument]. This is true that usually adverbs are made from the feminine form of the adjectives, BUT not for adjectives ending in -u!
  11. p.394: our soliders
  12. p.395 and p.408: je t’aime ma chère coeur [instead of: mon cher coeur]. Same problem as in #4: le coeur, the heart, is a masculine noun in French, so whether you use it in an expression to address a man or a woman, it does not matter, it remains in the masculine.

I may have missed some more, but these are already far too many. If you don’t understand French, it may not bother you, but seeing the topic, the author and editor should expect French readers to read this book and discover its poor editing work.

The book comprises:

  • a bibliography – so it seems the author did a lot of research to write this book. I believe her perspective could have been much deeper.
  • a French-English glossary
  • historical notes, somewhat explaining what the author added or adjusted
  • Questions and Topics for discussion – these are good!

Conclusion: I will not read the final book of the series, entitled The Last October Sky.

WHAT IS IT ABOUT

A captivating novel of rich spectacle and royal scandal, Days of Splendor, Days of Sorrow spans fifteen years in the fateful reign of Marie Antoinette, France’s most legendary and notorious queen.

Paris, 1774. At the tender age of eighteen, Marie Antoinette ascends to the French throne alongside her husband, Louis XVI. But behind the extravagance of the young queen’s elaborate silk gowns and dizzyingly high coiffures, she harbors deeper fears for her future and that of the Bourbon dynasty.

From the early growing pains of marriage to the joy of conceiving a child, from her passion for Swedish military attaché Axel von Fersen to the devastating Affair of the Diamond Necklace, Marie Antoinette tries to rise above the gossip and rivalries that encircle her. But as revolution blossoms in America, a much larger threat looms beyond the gilded gates of Versailles—one that could sweep away the French monarchy forever. (Goodreads)

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Juliet Grey has extensively researched European royal history and is a particular devotee of Marie Antoinette. She and her husband divide their time between New York City and southern Vermont. [Goodreads]

REVIEWS BY OTHER BLOGGERS

Peeking Between The Pages
Bippity Boppity Book

You might be interested in my post on La Conciergerie and Marie-Antoinette

HAVE YOU READ THIS BOOK YET?
DO YOU FEEL LIKE READING THIS BOOK?
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS  IN A COMMENT PLEASE

***

If you link your own post on France,
please if possible
include the title of the book or topic in your link:
name of your blog (name of the book title or topic).
Thanks

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “I love France #24: (2012) #34 Review: Days of Splendor, Days of Sorrow

  1. Pingback: Paris in July 2012 « Words And Peace

  2. Hi, I justed posted a link to my post on Guy de Maupassant non-fiction story of his lumch with Algernon Swinburne (really strange) and a link to an essay by Julian Barnes on the occasion-I highly recommend both works

    Like

  3. Pingback: 2012 Ebook Reading Challenge « Words And Peace

  4. Pingback: July wrap up « Words And Peace

  5. Pingback: 2nds Reading Challenge 2012 « Words And Peace

  6. Pingback: Historical Fiction Reading Challenge « Words And Peace

  7. Pingback: Confessions of Marie Antoinette: review. I love France #67 | Words And Peace

What do you think? Share your thoughts, and I will answer you. I will also visit your own blog

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.